Before Beth and I went to actually see Chris and Rich Robinson perform at the Fillmore during their acoustic Brothers of a Feather tour, I read a review of an earlier show that started with something like "There are few moments that can be called magical in rock n' roll history" and the writer could not have been more correct. First off, we were seeing a show at the Fillmore in San Francisco, which has musical history written all over it to begin with. When we first got to the venue my first impression was that it really doesn't look like too much from the outside. It's a fairly nondiscreet building standing next to a Post Office (which is where we had to line up for the show). Once inside though, you can see the old, grandiose style furnishings and architecture which adds to that legendary feel.
Up at the top of the stairs the Fillmore hands out apples for free, for you know….eating… or smoking out of. There was also a guy handing out Brothers of a Feather pins that Beth managed to somehow miss. Damnit woman. We had gotten there early to try and get one of the very limited seats that Beth's brothers had mentioned the place had, but when we walked into the main floor area we were greeted with a large selection of 8 person tables covered in black tableclothes to choose from. We made our way up to the front since we were some of the first people in and found some great seats probably 50 feet back from the stage if not closer. The great spot would later be ruined by a 300 lb. man who would sit directly in front of Beth approximately 30 seconds before the show started. I then grabbed some posters (I think only 400 were made for the entire tour), some t-shirts and drinks for us and got back to the table.
The show was weird in how security was handled. There were tons of signs telling people to shut off their cell phones at the request of the artist. So during the show there'd be people smoking up right next to me, but security would come flying by to nearly kick out some chick who pulled out her cell phone with the tell-tale blue light shining. Pretty funny. So, on the show…
Good Friday Chris and Rich came out on stage with 2 guitars by each of them, a table with some water and beers between them, and a coatrack in the back. After each taking a seat, Chris pulled out a harmonica and they started into Good Friday. They're so creative. It was Friday. Cool song and it was ironic that Chris' voice cracked during the word "awkward."
Horsehead I've always loved this riff and thought it was one of the better tunes from By Your Side. It sounds especially cool with Rich playing it on the electric with no bass or drums. The lack of the backing vocals also lets Chris have a bigger part in the chorus.
Girl from the North Country This was in my top 3 songs of the night. Absolutely killer version of a gorgeous Bob Dylan song with Chris and Rich trading vocals. Chris went nuts on the last chorus, blowing the version from New York out of the water.
Wyoming and Me Beautiful song that the brothers brought back for this tour. Unfortunately on the (yet) unreleased The Band album that lets Chris shine.
Under a Mountain Pretty much the same as the Storytellers version, but still neat to hear this mainly electric song played on the acoustic.
Long Black Veil Chris picked up a guitar for this and sung it perfectly with killer backing vocals from Rich. Dave Matthews, please take a seat, cause this is how the song is supposed to be played.
Leave it Alone Rich takes lead vocals here on a song from his solo album. Thankfully, it's my favorite one. I'm getting into more and more, but this is still probably the best song on it. It's nice to hear Chris doing the backup parts on this and hopefully it will find its way to the full band shows.
Train Robbers Another of my top 3 of the night here since it's one of my favorites from Chris' solo albums. Really great to hear them pull out material from their solo albums.
Soul Singing I think Beth mentioned this was her favorite from the night. Chris literally looked ready to jump out of his seat during parts of this. You could just tell how much he loves this song. It's simple and the 10 minute jam adds a lot during the full band versions, but this quick version was full of energy.
Magic Rooster Blues This was a new song which we both really liked. It was more up-tempo than the others I've heard and both Chris and Rich seemed to enjoy playing it. Wish I remembered it more, but I need to go find an mp3 of this somewhere.
How Much For Your Wings? This is a song that I honestly never got into and actually skip over once in a while, but wow… it was one of the highlights tonight. The harmonies between Chris and Rich sounded dead on and Rich playing this by himself on the 12 string added a whole dimension to it. Absolutely perfect.
Beware of Darkness A George Harrison cover that Chris picked out. It sounded great and we both really loved the lyrics to this one. I'll have to look it up eventually, but it was a really cool cover choice.
Darling of the Underground Press Love the riffs on this one. It doesn't get much play on the full band tours, but either Chris or Rich must really like it cause it's been playing fairly regularly on this tour. Probably Rich cause it sounds like a fun song to play. So the story goes that you sold your soul for delusions of beauty and courage.
Cut from the Shadow The second new song of the night, but this one was more subdued and musical based than lyrically. Almost seemed like more a jam between the two from what I remember.
You're a Big Girl Now I honestly have no recollection of this song being played and it surprised me to read it on the setlist. Oh well. Sorry.
Nonfiction Very Storytellers-esque as well, but it works well as an acoustic song.
She Talks to Angels Of course, the ultimate acoustic song in their catalog. This seemed to be very long and it looks like both of them really enjoy playing it. I can't blame them since although it's overplayed and one of the few songs casual fans know, it's a beautiful song about a bunch of different girls. (According to Chris). They closed the set with this one.
Let It Be Gone Rich sang the vocals on this and although I never heard the song before I was singing along by the end. Really catchy, fun tune.
You Don't Miss Your Water I know Beth really loved this cover from the Chicago show last Fall and before the show started I had mentioned they'd be playing it at a few shows already this tour, so I know she was excited to hear it again. It's a very cool song and a great way to end the show. I was pleasantly surprised with this as the show closer.
It really was one of the best shows I've ever seen. I hate to call it my favorite since it was just an acoustic show, but it was such a unique atmosphere and setting that I'll never forget it. I think we both had huge, stupid smiles on our faces the entire show. I know I had to go the bathroom real bad, but I didn't bother getting up for anything because I was so enveloped in the show. It was worth every penny of the trip out there and I would totally do it again if I could.